Indexly Review 2026: AI Search Visibility Tracking, Tested

Indexly Review 2026: AI Search Visibility Tracking, Tested

⚠️ Affiliate Disclosure: This post is not an affiliate associated review. It may become one in the future and this disclosure will reflect that. This does not affect my reviews and I only recommend tools I genuinely believe in.

Indexly Review

In this Indexly review I look at an AI search visibility platform, not a Google indexing tool: it tracks whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity and Grok mention your brand, how they describe it, and what content would get you cited. I cover what it does, what it costs (AI tracking from $49 a month; only the Analytics module is free) and who it suits. I scored it 6.5/10.

📅 Last updated: 12 November 2026

Traditional SEO tools track where you rank on Google. But what about ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Claude? Millions of searches now happen inside AI tools — and most businesses have no idea if they are being mentioned, recommended, or ignored. Indexly is built to fix that.

Indexly Review desktop screenshot

What is Indexly?

Indexly is a SEO and AI Search Visibility Platform that helps brands monitor and grow their presence across both traditional search engines (Google, Bing) and AI-powered platforms (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Perplexity). It covers three main areas: analysing how your brand appears in AI answers, creating content that gets cited by AI engines, and monitoring SEO and AI-driven traffic in one unified dashboard.

Indexly has grown quickly in the emerging Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) space, with features like AI prompt tracking, brand sentiment analysis, citation gap detection, and an auto-pilot content agent that publishes SEO-optimised articles to your CMS without manual intervention.

What Can You Do With Indexly?

Indexly tracks how AI engines see your brand and then acts on it. Here is what it covers.

  • Track visibility across AI platforms — Indexly monitors your brand on five or more AI engines at once.
  • Follow individual prompts — Indexly reports at query level rather than in aggregate.
  • Measure sentiment — Indexly reports how AI engines characterise your brand, not just whether they mention it.
  • Publish on autopilot — Indexly’s content agent can create and publish without manual steps.
  • Connect to your CMS — Indexly integrates with WordPress, Webflow and others.
  • Budget from $49 a month — single Indexly tools, including AI tracking, start at $49; only Analytics is free, and prompt tracking is capped by tier.

Indexly Pricing

Plan Monthly Price Team access Prompts Tracked Articles/mo
Starter $99/mo No 50 10
Growth $299/mo Yes 100 30
Scale $499/mo Yes 200 60
Enterprise Custom Custom Custom Custom

A 17% discount applies on annual billing (charged upfront for the year). There is also a done-for-you service starting at $299/site/month where Indexly handles everything from audit to content publishing. Apart from the free Analytics module, no free plan is listed, but you can book a demo before committing. Important: each “prompt tracked” is a question run across all monitored AI platforms each month — so 50 prompts means 50 questions checked across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, and Grok. Monthly prompt allowances reset each cycle and do not roll over.

Indexly now also sells its tools as separate products — SEO Visibility, AI Visibility, Content Agents, Social Agents, Forum Agents, Ads Agents and Analytics — alongside the bundled plans above. Single products start at $49 a month, and Analytics is free; every price is in the tables below. API access is listed on the Scale plan; the API uses one organisation-level key and is limited to 15 requests a minute. I checked these prices on indexly.ai on 27 October 2026.

Indexly Prices for Brands (per month)

Indexly productPriceWhat you get
Indexly One (everything)From $2992 sites; AI Visibility, Content, Social and Forum Agents, and Analytics
SEO Visibility$492 sites; Google and Bing indexing, keyword tracking, site audits, backlinks
AI Visibility$49 (Starter) or $99 (Growth)Starter: 1 site, 50 prompts, any 3 AI models, 1 country. Growth: 2 sites, 100 prompts tracked daily, any 3 AI models, 2 countries
Content Agents$992 sites; 30 articles a month, content refresh, one-click publishing
Social Agents$992 sites; LinkedIn, X and Instagram, 30 posts per channel a month
Forum Agents$492 sites; Reddit (Quora “coming soon”), 10 keywords per channel
AnalyticsFree2 sites; Google, Bing and AI traffic, leads and conversions
APIs & ReportsIncludedAPI access, custom reports, unlimited team members

Indexly Prices for Agencies (per month)

Indexly productStarter (3 sites)Growth (5 sites)Scale (10 sites)
Indexly One$695$1,045$1,795
SEO Visibility$99$149$299
AI Visibility$149 (150 prompts, 3 models)$249 (250 prompts, 4 models)$499 (500 prompts, 4 models)
Content Agents$199 (60 articles)$299 (150 articles)$499 (300 articles)
Social Agents$149$199$249
Forum Agents$99$149$249
AnalyticsFree (3 sites)
APIs & ReportsIncluded for all sites

Annual billing saves 17%, and neither pricing page mentions a free trial. One inconsistency on Indexly’s own site: the APIs & Reports tab says “Included”, but its plan comparison table lists API access on the Scale plan only. I checked all of these prices on indexly.ai on 27 October 2026, and rechecked the AI Visibility prices on 12 November 2026, when a new $49 Starter tier had appeared. Indexly’s sign-up buttons now say “Get Started at $1”, without saying what the $1 covers.

A note for Indexly lifetime-deal buyers: I bought Indexly’s Agency lifetime deal with my own money in May 2025. In October 2026 my account was locked, and not for the first time: it showed no plan and no invoices, and asked me to upgrade from $99 a month. I contacted Indexly’s support chat on 21 October and sent my invoice reference on 23 October. It took six days, several follow-ups and a message saying I would update this review before my access was restored on 27 October, with an apology for the delay. My account now shows as a managed account. If you bought an early lifetime deal and your dashboard looks empty, contact support before you pay again, and keep your invoice reference handy.

Key Use Cases

Indexly is particularly valuable for businesses that rely on brand discoverability in an AI-first world. Key use cases include tracking which AI engines mention your brand and with what sentiment, monitoring prompts like “best [category] tool” to see if you appear, identifying citation gaps (what content you need to get AI citations), auto-publishing SEO and GEO-optimised articles to WordPress, Webflow, or Ghost, monitoring Reddit threads where your brand or category is discussed, and providing agencies with white-label AI visibility reports for clients.

What Happened When I Tested Indexly’s Content and Social Agents?

Once my account was restored on 27 October 2026, I tried two of Indexly’s writing tools on WhatAITools. Neither result was good.

Indexly’s Social Writer made things up

I gave Indexly’s Social Writer a detailed brief for a LinkedIn post about my Novelcrafter test: my 7/10 score, the fact that Novelcrafter comes with no AI, my own quote, and a note to write in the first person in British English with a link to the review. The draft it produced:

  • Pasted my instructions into the post: “First person, British English, link to whataitools.co.uk/novelcrafter-review/” appeared word for word in the middle of the text.
  • Switched to “we” (“our hands-on review”, “When we analysed the workflow”), when I asked for first person.
  • Added statistics I never gave it: it credited a “2025 review by Selfpublishing.com” and a “2024 survey of over 1,200 authors” by BookBub saying 85% use ChatGPT and 54% use Claude. I hadn’t supplied any of these, and I haven’t been able to check them.

Despite all that, Indexly gave the draft an AEO score of 90, labelled “Citation Ready”, with 7 of 8 checks passed. The one check it failed asked for more outside sources. A score that rates invented statistics and leftover instructions as citation-ready is not a score I can trust. Indexly does warn, in small print, that you should review the content before publishing. On this evidence you would need to rewrite it, not just review it.

Indexly’s Content Opportunities got my site wrong

I ran Indexly’s Content Opportunities on my “AI Tool Discovery And Reviews” topic. It took around five minutes and returned 17 article ideas, most marked “Critical”. A few were useful, such as a guide to evaluating an AI tool before paying and a “best AI tool review sites” page. But it said WhatAITools had “zero” small business list when my best AI tools for small business guide is live. It also treated Zapier vs Make as a gap when I already have a Zapier vs Make comparison. Most of its ideas were “best X tools” lists that would mean ranking tools I haven’t tested, which I won’t do. Use it as a brainstorm, and check each “gap” against your own site before you act on it. A later list of 25 ideas repeated the mistake: it said WhatAITools publishes “zero UK-specific content”, and suggested a Jasper vs Copy.ai comparison and a guide to why AI gets things wrong, when the site quotes UK prices in pounds throughout and both of those pages already exist. After I fixed Indexly’s sitemap and blog settings and regenerated the list, it still suggested a “best AI tools for content creators” guide I’d already published, and it never removes suggestions that are out of date. Its Content Refresh feature, which updates existing articles, isn’t self-serve either: Indexly’s team has to confirm your blog has been publishing for at least 90 days and switch it on for you.

What Happened When I Checked Indexly’s Tracking Data?

Tracking is what Indexly is for, so I checked its figures against Google and against each other. In November 2026, Indexly showed 0% visibility in Google AI Overviews for all 10 review prompts I track. When I opened the answers behind that figure, there weren’t any: Indexly said “No prompt responses found”. It hadn’t collected a single AI Overview answer, but showed the gap as a measured 0%. When I checked the same 10 prompts by hand on Google UK, WhatAITools was cited in the AI Overview for 8 of them.

The schedule didn’t hold either. I set tracking to run three times a week, on Wednesday, Friday and Sunday. In the first week it ran once, on a Saturday, while the dashboard said “Updates every week”. I raised it with Indexly support twice.

Some of Indexly’s own pages disagree with each other. The Overview gave WhatAITools a sentiment score of 48/100, while the Sentiments page ranked it first with 71.88% net sentiment. The AI Readiness page showed a score of 96/100 from a July audit that had checked zero pages. And Indexly’s Brand Hub had set my UK site to the United States and US Eastern Time, with no tone of voice, which helps explain why its Social Writer wrote as “we”. I corrected those settings myself.

To be fair, the Citations report was the most useful part of Indexly. When AI answers mentioned WhatAITools, my site was the second most-cited source after Reddit, ahead of TechRadar. That’s real, usable data. The problem is knowing which of Indexly’s other numbers you can trust.

What Are the Downsides of Indexly?

Indexly is priced at a level more suited to growing businesses and agencies than individual bloggers or very small teams — the Starter plan at $99/month is still a meaningful commitment. The prompt tracking limits (50–200 per month) may feel restricting for brands with large product portfolios. The platform is relatively new and some features are still maturing. It does not replace a full technical SEO tool for in-depth site auditing — it complements one rather than replacing Ahrefs or Semrush.

Indexly is also hard to automate. There’s no Indexly connector for Claude, so every check for this review was done in the Indexly dashboard itself. Indexly does have an API, but it’s read-only and its documentation lists just three endpoints: one to check your API key, one for a site’s visibility history and one for brand and competitor figures. It can’t change your tracking schedule, start a run or add prompts, so you can’t use it to automate your tracking.

Indexly Review: Pros & Cons

Indexly Pros

  • Tracks brand visibility across 5+ AI platforms simultaneously
  • AI prompt tracking at a query level
  • Brand sentiment analysis across AI engines
  • Auto-pilot content agent for hands-free publishing
  • Integrates with WordPress, Webflow, Ghost, Zapier
  • Reddit monitoring for AI-adjacent brand mentions
  • White-label option for agencies
  • API access with an organisation-level key (Scale plan)

Indexly Cons

  • No free tracking plan; AI Visibility starts at $49/month for one site
  • Prompt tracking limits may restrict large brands
  • Not a replacement for full technical SEO tools
  • Relatively new platform — features still evolving
  • No Claude connector, and the API is read-only (three endpoints), so you can’t automate tracking with it
  • Showed 0% in Google AI Overviews for all 10 of my tracked prompts without having collected a single AI Overview answer
  • Set to track three times a week, it ran once in its first week, on a day I hadn’t chosen
  • My lifetime-deal account was locked; support took six days to restore it
  • Social Writer invented statistics and still scored the draft 90, “Citation Ready”
  • Content Opportunities flagged “gaps” for pages I already have
  • Higher tiers needed for full AI model coverage (Grok on Scale)

Who Is Indexly For?

Indexly is best suited to SaaS companies, digital marketing agencies, and content-driven businesses that want to stay visible as search shifts toward AI-generated answers. If your target customers are asking ChatGPT or Perplexity for recommendations and you want to make sure your brand is being mentioned, Indexly provides the tracking and content infrastructure to make that happen. It is particularly strong for agencies that want to offer AI visibility reporting as a new service line.

Is Indexly Good? My Verdict

Partly — Indexly is useful for tracking, but you can’t take its numbers on trust. I scored it 6.5/10 in my WhatAITools review. It tracks brand visibility across five or more AI platforms at query level, measures sentiment, and can publish content on autopilot. There is no free tracking plan and AI Visibility starts at $49 a month for one site, so it suits businesses already investing in SEO.

Indexly is solving a real and growing problem: most businesses are invisible in AI search and do not even know it. The platform brings genuine data to a space that has been mostly guesswork until now. The pricing is justified for businesses where AI-driven discovery matters, and the auto-pilot content agent adds strong practical value. For anyone serious about GEO and AI search visibility, Indexly is a tool worth trialling.

My one big warning: do not let Indexly’s writing agents publish for you unchecked. In my test, its Social Writer invented statistics and still called the draft “Citation Ready”. Use Indexly for the tracking, and write the content yourself. And check its tracking too: it showed 0% visibility in Google AI Overviews for prompts where it had collected no AI Overview answers at all, while I found my site cited in 8 of 10 by hand.

Indexly Review Rating: 6.5/10

Every tool I review is signed up for and tested by hand. See how I test and score.

Indexly Score Breakdown

Output quality7/10ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity tracking and the Citations report are useful, but it showed 0% in Google AI Overviews without collecting any answers, and its writing agents invented statistics
Ease of use8.5/10Quick to set up and read
Features8/10Focused rather than broad; not a replacement for full technical SEO
Value for money7/10No free tracking plan, AI Visibility from $49 a month, and my paid lifetime deal was locked for six days before support restored it
Overall score6.5/10The Citations report is genuinely useful, but its AI Overview figures, schedule and writing agents all need checking, priced for businesses already investing in SEO
Overall score is my own judgement, not an average of the categories.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Indexly worth it?

Only if you check its data yourself — I scored Indexly 6.5/10 on WhatAITools. It tracks brand visibility across five or more AI platforms at query level and can publish content automatically. At $49 a month for AI Visibility on one site, with no free tracking plan, it is not a tool to try speculatively.

What AI platforms does Indexly track?

Indexly tracks brand visibility across ChatGPT (OpenAI), Claude (Anthropic), Gemini (Google), Perplexity, and Grok (xAI). The number of AI models tracked depends on your plan.

Is there a free trial?

Indexly does not currently advertise a self-serve free trial, but you can book a demo to see the platform in action before purchasing.

Does Indexly replace Ahrefs or Semrush?

No — it complements them. Indexly focuses on AI search visibility and GEO, while Ahrefs and Semrush focus on traditional SEO metrics like backlinks and keyword rankings. For a complete picture, you would use both.

Can Indexly publish content automatically?

Yes. The Auto-Pilot Engine feature (available on Growth and Scale plans) can generate and publish SEO/GEO-optimised articles directly to WordPress, Webflow, or Ghost on a set schedule.

Can I cancel my Indexly subscription?

Yes — contact Indexly to cancel your subscription. Monthly plans can be cancelled before the next renewal date with no further charge. Annual plans are billed upfront for the full year; check Indexly’s terms for their refund policy on annual subscriptions as this varies. Given the pricing level, it is worth booking a demo and thoroughly testing before committing to an annual plan.

Alternatives to Indexly

If you are exploring the AI visibility and SEO space, here are some alternatives to Indexly that I’ve reviewed:

  • NeuronWriter — Better for hands-on SEO content creation rather than AI visibility monitoring
  • Creaitor — Includes basic GEO features at a lower price point, better for content teams
  • Ranked AI — Managed SEO service that now includes AI search visibility tracking

More AI Tool Reviews

Base44 Bubble ChatGPT Claude AI Copy.ai Creaitor.ai ElevenLabs ElevenLabs Hostinger Horizons Midjourney n8n n8n NeuronWriter Perplexity AI Ranked AI Replit Surfer SEO Surfer SEO Writesonic Zapier

See how Indexly compares with seven other tools I’ve tested in my best AI SEO tools ranking.

See how Indexly compares with the other AI visibility tools I’ve tested in my best AI visibility tools ranking.

James Huntington
James Huntington
AI Tools Expert

James is an SEO and content specialist with over 12 years’ experience, and tests AI tools so everyday people don’t have to. WhatAITools.co.uk covers honest, no-jargon reviews to help you find the right tool for your needs.

LinkedIn · Follow on 𝕏 (Twitter / X)


Tried this tool?

Has Indexly's AI visibility data matched what you see when you check ChatGPT or Google yourself? Share your experience below.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *