Which AI music generator is best? In my testing, Suno (8/10) is the most complete, Nafy AI (7.5/10) has the better vocals, and Udio (4/10) no longer lets you download what you make. See my Suno vs Udio vs Nafy AI comparison for the full side-by-side. AI music generators create songs, instrumentals and soundtracks from a text prompt. I test them on real briefs, covering audio quality, vocals, prompt control and the licensing terms that decide whether you can use what you make.
-
My Udio review: it missed my style brief in a same-lyrics test, and since its label settlements you can’t download your music at all. I scored it 4/10.
-
My Suno review: finished songs with strong vocals from a simple prompt, plus stem splitting — though longer tracks can lose their way. I scored it 8/10.


